Painter Publishes Study Fact-Checking “The Big Lie”

June 23, 2022

By Stephanie Rizzo ’09

Communication professor David Painter looks at whether exposure to fact-checking has the power to sway those who believe false information about current events.

David Painter
David PainterPhoto by Scott Cook.

Communication professor David Painter has a new study out that examines “The Big Lie,” i.e. the false yet pervasive idea that the 2020 election was plagued by systemic fraud. The study was a joint project between Painter and University of Florida professor Juliana Fernandez and included more than 300 Rollins students, faculty, and staff in its sample size.

The study looks at whether exposure to fact-checking has the power to sway those who believe false information about current events, specifically as it relates to current U.S. politics.

Fernandez and Painter first polled participants to gather a sense of their demographic and political-party affiliation. Then participants answered a series of questions from the Cognitive Reflexivity Test, which measures the use of critical versus intuitive thinking. Finally, participants were randomly assigned to either: (1) a treatment condition where they read the Associated Press’ election-fraud fact-checking article from; or (2) a control condition with an article about birdwatching from Birdwatcher’s Digest as a placebo. 

After exposure to the stimuli, participants completed a post-test questionnaire that included measures of the election’s legitimacy and characterizations of the Capitol Hill attack on January 6.

Fernandez and Painter concluded that exposure to fact-checking information, critical thinking skills, and affiliation with the Democratic Party were positively related to participants’ beliefs in the election’s legitimacy and characterization of the Capitol Hill attacks as violent and extreme. Further, their findings suggest Republican and pro-Trump participants who rely on intuitive (versus critical) thinking are more likely to believe false claims of election fraud and may find violence an acceptable means of achieving their goals.

“As a communication professor, political communication scholar, and fake-news expert, this project allowed me to explore how people’s critical thinking influences their political beliefs, especially when they believe lies in the face of overwhelming contradictory evidence,” says Painter. “My job at Rollins is to foster my students critical thinking skills, and this study suggests that those skills translate into more accurate beliefs about our world and the rejection of political violence.”

Read More

April 08, 2024

The Legacy of Fred Rogers '51 Lives on in Rollins' Music Department

Fred Rogers' nephew Dan Crozier, a professor of music at Rollins College, shares thoughts and memories of his uncle and previews the Mister Rogers: The Musician concert.

April 03, 2024

What It’s Like to Be a Rollins Student-Athlete

Rollins’ winning combination of academic and athletic excellence empowers student-athletes like Ben Kopen ’24 to thrive both on and off the field.

March 27, 2024

Rollins Inducts 24 New Members of Phi Beta Kappa

On March 19, the Rollins chapter of Phi Beta Kappa—known as Theta Chapter of Florida—inducted its third class of members.